Reddit head-to-head· Gaming
EA Sports FC vs CD Projekt Red on Reddit
Reddit compares EA Sports FC's stagnant graphics and nostalgia for old titles with CD Projekt Red's post-launch redemption and strong single-player experiences.
Public example report. Your own comparison searches stay private and are never published.
The verdict
CD Projekt Red clearly wins in Reddit sentiment. Their recovery from Cyberpunk 2077's launch, commitment to post-release support, and focus on high-quality single-player experiences like The Witcher 3 have largely rebuilt trust, while EA Sports FC struggles with persistent graphical issues and community mockery.
EA Sports FC
r/classictrek, r/chelseafc, r/nhlcirclejerk, r/soccer, r/datingro
CD Projekt Red
r/topcharactertropes, r/arknights, r/witcher3, r/witcher, r/gaming
Head to head
| Dimension | EA Sports FC | CD Projekt Red |
|---|---|---|
| Reddit reputation | Perceived as consistently failing on graphical accuracy, leading to annual mockery and resignation. | Has largely rebuilt trust through post-launch support for Cyberpunk 2077, despite past missteps. |
| Risks | Continued graphical blunders and lack of innovation risk alienating players who are already 'done dirty'. | Announcing games too early creates backlash, and unoptimised games, especially on Unreal Engine, are a significant concern. |
| Opportunities | A strong nostalgic pull for older game versions and community efforts to revive them indicate a desire for simpler, satisfying experiences. | Sustained demand for 'evergreen' titles like The Witcher 3 and appreciation for robust localisation offer long-term engagement. |
| Price talk | No specific price talk, but older versions offer better value, implying new titles are overpriced for their quality. | Players resent aggressive pricing of DLC and microtransactions, despite appreciating the core games. |
| Support talk | Community support focuses on reviving older games due to perceived issues with newer iterations and lack of official support for legacy titles. | Praised for post-release support and fixing issues, contrasting with general resentment for unoptimized games and broken promises. |
EA Sports FC
What Reddit likes
- •Strong nostalgic pull for older game versions, highlighting enduring appeal.
- •Demand for next-gen sports experiences despite flaws, indicating a core fanbase.
- •Older titles becoming more accessible on various platforms, broadening play base.
Watch-outs
- •Persistent failure in game graphics and player likenesses, leading to widespread mockery.
- •Players feel 'done dirty' by inaccurate in-game athlete renders, causing genuine frustration.
- •Community questioning developer competence due to repeated visual inaccuracies.
Choose EA Sports FC if: You prioritize sports titles and are willing to overlook persistent graphical issues for the gameplay, or enjoy the nostalgia of older versions.
CD Projekt Red
What Reddit likes
- •Successful post-launch redemption of Cyberpunk 2077, rebuilding significant trust.
- •Creation of 'evergreen' titles like The Witcher 3 with sustained sales and value.
- •Appreciation for strong regionalisation and localisation, enhancing global appeal.
Watch-outs
- •Gamer fatigue with unoptimised games, especially on Unreal Engine.
- •Developer announcements too early, leading to frustrating waits and potential backlash.
- •Fear of game updates breaking existing mods, a significant concern for PC players.
Choose CD Projekt Red if: You value deep, evolving single-player experiences and developer commitment to post-launch fixes, even if initial releases are rocky.
Common questions
Why do Reddit users mock EA Sports FC graphics?
Reddit users mock EA Sports FC graphics due to the consistent lack of realism and inaccurate player likenesses, which is seen as an annual failure despite technological advancements.
How did CD Projekt Red rebuild trust after Cyberpunk 2077's launch?
CD Projekt Red rebuilt trust through dedicated post-release support, significant bug fixes, and content additions like the Phantom Liberty expansion, which greatly improved the game's quality and sentiment.
What is the community's stance on older EA Sports FC (FIFA) games?
There is a strong nostalgic pull and enduring loyalty for older EA Sports FC (FIFA) titles, with players actively reviving and preferring them for their features or simpler, more satisfying experiences over newer iterations.