Reddit head-to-head· Gaming
Cyberpunk 2077 vs Elden Ring on Reddit
Reddit compares Cyberpunk 2077's post-launch redemption and value against Elden Ring's enduring challenge and community culture.
Public example report. Your own comparison searches stay private and are never published.
The verdict
Cyberpunk 2077 wins on Reddit sentiment for its 'redemption loyalty' and setting a new standard for AAA value, offering a narrative of developer turnaround. Elden Ring, while deeply loved for its challenge and community, faces frustrations over lore presentation and grind, preventing it from matching Cyberpunk's current goodwill on user value.
Cyberpunk 2077
r/multifandom, r/topcharacterdesigns, r/steam, r/indiangaming, r/lgbt
Elden Ring
r/gaming, r/eldenring, r/fromsoftware, r/casualuk, r/malelivingspace
Head to head
| Dimension | Cyberpunk 2077 | Elden Ring |
|---|---|---|
| Reddit reputation | Praised for 'redemption loyalty' and post-launch developer 'love and care' after past issues. | Fosters a 'deep, almost familial, affection' for its world and a playful community culture. |
| Risks | Regional pricing barriers alienate players in emerging markets, seen as 'scummy practices'. | Lore and character development (e.g., Melina) are sometimes seen as underutilized or hidden, frustrating players. |
| Opportunities | High value perception, with users seeing it as a 'gold standard' for post-launch content and rejecting Denuvo-like practices. | Deep replayability encourages players to constantly find 'new, obscure ways' to engage and 'break' the game. |
| Price talk | Current state is seen as a 'gold standard for AAA value', despite regional pricing being a 'massive barrier'. | Not explicitly mentioned, but community engagement and replayability suggest long-term value, offsetting grind concerns. |
| Support talk | Users actively thank CDPR for 'love and care' in post-launch content, indicating strong positive sentiment for developer support. | Community offers 'shared triumph' and support for new players facing brutal challenges, rather than developer support directly. |
Cyberpunk 2077
What Reddit likes
- •High 'redemption loyalty' and gratitude for post-launch content and developer care.
- •Considered a 'gold standard' for AAA value, rejecting practices like Denuvo.
- •Community-led 'DLSS 5' breakthrough highlights user-driven hardware optimization.
Watch-outs
- •Regional pricing creates a 'massive barrier' for players in emerging markets.
- •'Ultra realism' mods are often dismissed as 'playable screenshots' with limited actual gameplay utility.
- •A significant portion of the 25 million players is 'missing out' by not owning the Phantom Liberty expansion.
Choose Cyberpunk 2077 if: you value a strong redemption story, developer support, and modern AAA features with strong narrative appeal.
Elden Ring
What Reddit likes
- •Deep community engagement thrives on sharing gaming journeys and overcoming challenges.
- •Transcends gaming, becoming a cultural touchstone with its aesthetic and difficulty.
- •Encourages finding creative ways to 'break' the game, not just play it straight.
Watch-outs
- •Lore and character development (e.g., Melina) can feel underutilized or hidden.
- •Non-somber weapon upgrade system is a 'notorious grind' that pushes players to specific weapon types.
- •Accidental teleportation to high-level zones can be a frustrating 'brutal rite of passage' for new players.
Choose Elden Ring if: you seek a challenging open-world experience with deep replayability and a strong, humorous community.
Common questions
How does Reddit view the value proposition of Cyberpunk 2077 vs. Elden Ring?
Reddit sees Cyberpunk 2077's current state as the 'gold standard for AAA value' due to its post-launch improvements. Elden Ring's value comes from deep replayability and community engagement despite lore and grind issues.
What are the main community sentiments surrounding each game?
Cyberpunk 2077 garners 'redemption loyalty' and thanks for developer care, while Elden Ring inspires 'deep, almost familial, affection' and a playful, self-aware humor among its community.
Which game is better for players looking for hardware innovation?
Cyberpunk 2077, as its community actively engaged in 'DLSS 5' breakthroughs, indicating a desire for software to extend hardware life and skepticism towards hardware manufacturers.