Reddit head-to-head· Gaming
ASUS ROG vs Elden Ring on Reddit
ASUS ROG users flex integrated setups but face phone quality issues. Elden Ring fosters a deep community, celebrating challenge and lore, despite grind and early game frustrations.
Public example report. Your own comparison searches stay private and are never published.
The verdict
Elden Ring clearly wins on Reddit sentiment, driven by a deep, affectionate community, shared triumphs, and sustained engagement. ASUS ROG, while enjoying hardcore loyalty for its ecosystem, suffers significant backlash over mobile hardware failures and perceptions of excessive pricing, diminishing overall brand enthusiasm.
ASUS ROG
r/pcbuild, r/pcmasterrace, r/pakgamers, r/gadgetsindia, r/noctua
Elden Ring
r/gaming, r/eldenring, r/fromsoftware, r/casualuk, r/malelivingspace
Head to head
| Dimension | ASUS ROG | Elden Ring |
|---|---|---|
| Reddit reputation | Hardcore loyalty within its niche for high-end, integrated setups, but a significant backlash against ROG phones for quality issues. | A deep, almost familial affection for the game and its safe spaces, with immense pride in overcoming challenges. |
| Risks | ASUS ROG phones' reputation for motherboard failures post-warranty significantly damages brand trust for mobile products. | Underutilized lore and character development, like Melina's, risk diminishing the emotional investment for some players. |
| Opportunities | Deep customisation and SFF trends offer avenues for continued innovation and engagement beyond off-the-shelf components. | The community's continued discovery of new ways to engage indicates strong replayability and potential for ongoing content or community-driven events. |
| Price talk | High-end components like the RTX 5090 are seen as ridiculously overpriced and unattainable, leading to resentment among many gamers. | Not applicable; discussions focus on game value and difficulty, not price. |
| Support talk | Motherboard failures right after warranty on ROG phones leave users with expensive, unsupported devices, indicating poor post-purchase support. | Community support is high, with players sharing strategies and celebrating milestones, filling gaps in game-provided guidance. |
ASUS ROG
What Reddit likes
- •Fosters hardcore loyalty among users showcasing expensive, integrated setups.
- •Strong ecosystem integration appeals to users prioritising cohesive aesthetics and functionality.
- •Significant engagement in customisation, with users modding gear beyond off-the-shelf components.
Watch-outs
- •ASUS ROG phones face a huge backlash for perceived poor quality and post-warranty motherboard failures.
- •High-end GPUs are viewed as ridiculously overpriced and unattainable, leading to resentment.
- •New PC builds can be a struggle for experienced builders, indicating potential complexity or component interaction issues.
Choose ASUS ROG if: You prioritize a complete, high-end, aesthetically cohesive gaming ecosystem and are wary of their mobile phone division.
Elden Ring
What Reddit likes
- •Cultivates a deep, almost familial affection for its world, characters, and challenges.
- •Promotes a strong, playful, and self-aware community celebrating shared triumphs and humor.
- •Offers immense replayability and constant discovery, even years after release.
Watch-outs
- •The upgrade system for non-somber weapons is considered a notorious grind, potentially frustrating players.
- •Accidental teleportation to high-level zones without clear escape routes creates brutal, frustrating experiences for new players.
- •Lore and character development (e.g., Melina's) can feel underutilised or hidden, disappointing lore enthusiasts.
Choose Elden Ring if: You seek a challenging, deeply engaging open-world experience with a vibrant, supportive community and significant replay value.
Common questions
Is ASUS ROG good for SFF builds?
Yes, Small Form Factor (SFF) builds are a significant trend among ASUS ROG users, pushing cooling and component selection in tight spaces.
Why are some users frustrated with Elden Ring's progression?
Frustration stems from the notorious grind of the non-somber weapon upgrade system and the brutal experience of accidentally being teleported to high-level zones without an escape.
What is the biggest risk for ASUS ROG?
The biggest risk is the significant backlash and damage to brand trust due to ROG phone motherboard failures occurring right after the warranty expires.