Reddit head-to-head· Gaming
ASUS ROG vs CD Projekt Red on Reddit
ASUS ROG excels in premium PC hardware with strong ecosystem loyalty, while CD Projekt Red rebuilt trust with post-launch game fixes and evergreen titles.
Public example report. Your own comparison searches stay private and are never published.
The verdict
CD Projekt Red currently enjoys stronger positive Reddit sentiment, primarily due to their successful recovery from Cyberpunk 2077's launch and consistent post-release support. ASUS ROG, while having a loyal base for PC hardware, faces significant backlash over its mobile division's quality issues and high-priced components.
ASUS ROG
r/pcbuild, r/pcmasterrace, r/pakgamers, r/gadgetsindia, r/noctua
CD Projekt Red
r/topcharactertropes, r/arknights, r/witcher3, r/witcher, r/gaming
Head to head
| Dimension | ASUS ROG | CD Projekt Red |
|---|---|---|
| Reddit reputation | Hardcore loyalty within the PC hardware niche, but negative sentiment for ROG phones due to quality. | Rebuilt trust with post-launch support for Cyberpunk 2077, leading to high regard for current titles. |
| Risks | Motherboard failures post-warranty for ROG phones tarnish brand image and erode trust. | Early game announcements and unoptimised releases risk repeating past mistakes and undermining current goodwill. |
| Opportunities | SFF and full ecosystem integration offer avenues for innovation and continued market dominance in premium PC builds. | Sustained success of 'evergreen' titles and demand for developer transparency can deepen player engagement. |
| Price talk | High-end GPUs are seen as ridiculously overpriced and often unattainable, causing resentment. | Players resent aggressive pricing of DLC and manipulative microtransactions, despite appreciating core game value. |
| Support talk | A common struggle for users to get PC builds to work, even for experienced builders. | 'Fixing it in post' strategy post-launch is praised, rebuilding trust for major titles like Cyberpunk 2077. |
ASUS ROG
What Reddit likes
- •Strong customisation culture, with users actively modding and showcasing their gear.
- •Dominant presence in luxury gaming setups, with users flexing high-end components.
- •Deep user loyalty and pride within its specific PC hardware niche for integrated setups.
Watch-outs
- •ROG phones have a reputation for motherboard failures right after warranty, creating expensive 'bricks'.
- •RTX 5090 and similar high-end components are often deemed ridiculously overpriced and unattainable.
- •Even experienced builders often struggle to get new PC builds to work correctly initially.
Choose ASUS ROG if: You value premium, customisable PC hardware and a cohesive aesthetic for your gaming ecosystem, accepting higher costs.
CD Projekt Red
What Reddit likes
- •Successful post-launch support and 'fixing it in post' for major titles, rebuilding player trust.
- •Ability to create 'evergreen' titles like The Witcher 3 with sustained sales years after release.
- •Strong regionalisation and localisation efforts, showing respect for diverse audiences.
Watch-outs
- •Gamers are frustrated with unoptimised games and developers making empty promises.
- •Announcing games too early creates backlash when development stalls or waiting games become frustrating.
- •Fear of game updates breaking existing mods is a significant concern for PC players.
Choose CD Projekt Red if: You seek immersive, evolving game experiences from developers who show commitment to post-launch fixes and value 'evergreen' content.
Common questions
Why is ASUS ROG's mobile division facing backlash?
Reddit sentiment indicates that ASUS ROG phones have a reputation for motherboard failures shortly after the warranty expires, leading to expensive, non-functional devices.
How did CD Projekt Red rebuild trust after Cyberpunk 2077?
They rebuilt trust through significant post-launch support, effectively 'fixing it in post,' with Cyberpunk 2077 (especially with Phantom Liberty) now highly regarded by many players.
What are Reddit's main concerns about game development practices?
Users are tired of unoptimised games, developers announcing titles too early, and the risk of game updates breaking existing mods, alongside aggressive monetisation practices.